From 42cc0a3645a1844af02305292c6dfc5f70515680 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Edgar P. Burkhart" Date: Fri, 6 May 2022 14:54:12 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Add comparison between keps and komega-sst --- report/chapters/olaflow.tex | 10 +++++++++- report/fig/diffsst175.pdf | Bin 0 -> 12360 bytes 2 files changed, 9 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 report/fig/diffsst175.pdf diff --git a/report/chapters/olaflow.tex b/report/chapters/olaflow.tex index 7d4b2dc..875a237 100644 --- a/report/chapters/olaflow.tex +++ b/report/chapters/olaflow.tex @@ -100,8 +100,16 @@ The value of $b$ seems to have a major effect how wave energy is dissipated / ho A case with the $k-\omega$ SST turbulence model was run to compare with the $k-\varepsilon$ model. Results displayed in \autoref{fig:sst}. Significant differences are found between both models. +Wave breaking as expected using SST model (\autoref{fig:sst175}). See +\url{https://public.edgarpierre.fr/anim_olaflow_kom.mp4} + \begin{figure} \centering \includegraphics{diffsst.pdf} - \caption{Case 1: $k-\varepsilon$ model; case 2: $k-\omega$ SST model.}\label{fig:sst} + \caption{$x=\SI{-50}{\m}$. Case 1: $k-\varepsilon$ model; case 2: $k-\omega$ SST model.}\label{fig:sst} +\end{figure} +\begin{figure} + \centering + \includegraphics{diffsst175.pdf} + \caption{$t=\SI{175}{\s}$. Case 1: $k-\varepsilon$ model; case 2: $k-\omega$ SST model.}\label{fig:sst175} \end{figure} diff --git a/report/fig/diffsst175.pdf b/report/fig/diffsst175.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..76311bcc783cdad4dd08c36dc90d4de1535e5b80 GIT binary patch literal 12360 zcmb`t2RzmP7eAhmvdSv5u8|e)zV5ZMvbQo5*PhpPT_O@fWUtIrR#rw7Ns?70R5G$x zh$1PY^?SdmPxJr%_xL@29*>vT`=0k}JkNQZ*E#3)dY?o3DykB2Nfhm&(qTwR9W5LJ zgLv4u(8|g}p!#@6doKtApcq1+$NY%)5U4VqjCb>JgviU&+7s-+hS;Av9Q7ru8Ikd1 zdkAW~ld1=S3_)%`>*L8}dlCVH27l5*^+_JKM)qWg1u&0_DlopiFBt;Wa0lj8`c^A{ zt2H2&5U7z8-p-le2*GT3H`TLov9~2dq_zhC0SEpw1BwKK2iXe(hixNJ2GH0O00M6N zw~oD?GhWHV7r+3vKp_zj1RMiSrjI894YygRg&Nv>d3cj-0a<{|{wE7iJU7 zRGr-bULjCbH$WIF_O>2&fb6vG365kZ2z*zno5LMO@cCez40E6-H? z{hM|97tOWgnTrRQPPFseDdNHv@P;i%)o1!=v)(M+UXzO(Tc_3&p}gf7iMnIg^n56v%&%Ho1yAAq#4RUM&Ym>djlij?N zdMUBx9Uo@L^sag6>d80tq_V#qoIm!_-0>|T3T5V6;`KCWQ+k%`bI=!}%B<;`YQ-cP zIvSMFrt|IYfJ=2BCgt5L8_Xqa#lHqLeDd4y^jk?F+1CZcj#xXEK<{OByl_kye6$?y zp3U-vTI&XUVQ_Qr9A4)dRL@HM$lZ**poTjd>bnxozdk-Nw2nO!ja;8uWeJ2nI#1n~ zQU2mu-&2=&N2|-5FWj0LjC%G!FID(#{Lzk;)y$-F?{#rYh9euR9@p-P-%B!I8Csdwb;#``$vk$|@&aYyc*kpKK(rFA}PU@*5z z;;AtUZ?WSl*97NAAYGIRN2*~T{J5KWiiK$ZTJVZ|-_yLzEEaN*NB$>#RKI9VoiW_4 zqGU|d&u_1YNqWh9hrqUOin|HRG_Ni5Egn(fY*~$Na?XEP3x0jo)zi&6`|9!odY_p%Ki=W3c^?ilI(da_}2 zB&u9~;M&)-m&W83p$n|kt+VbcjQ3_XMm#ECy(+)I_EMxGtWZ%5nN`dFN_~M8b7#fk z2Ih%E+=bxT($~w6OSvU@Ol7LpPcJ;}muDqQOg41P9naUkY~o}jv-06tq=S5(qUd4S zQ!7-~H$z$O4R)R#&7VzVPc9UEIqBf*lFwJ5>JjmZP~y7gBG~@&Le5LuUGf&tR==}I ztIE^R)yY_PpL7YLTL}Z_!P<=X2~!OAto>O*{?t*Yh^Z6IwOZbGq)B&%wY-hWTkX0+ zM9X|U^Q1b$y|?XHSkyD=D6u8;#>`Xmm098FXvs1qO*&9!_DoNn;FgFc%`b@eR{{ z&H2V$*0{)vn|~d;Eb28nff3VSKNL%0;?p$1r+Q~sEVDW4VlL$Y?aq{`o6l{W+k)2G zWohd*=kM-{-5EVB=T(nB;b+%u!EKNh949}E;n6L$HGSb(8}h&>;o4n?296t={X+K( z)}?6;k54juNhI_4bX4@Ai3=F57jQ<}S&A;Qm3#9|DSdvor^kpdC zsqlP3Lhj5}$aMx^e;uyTxprOKi_2HDpVh^1Ji8VAcG-I9q5x9qSVCO9%V{iUrm$dE z#h3zHgM<9R#me#O`?{`&Z>SaFM$_C$qje$9S)Nag#;2Tlb?Hp1IBG-M@~S3}DZ~j$ zVgu=99-hKZJbia;+&R4nwr^g#{Qc^#ihUafgKw`=tdf<&&8Vo~K5enNN5o+9Ps_tT zo9!uA3M;a_^|q0TrW{uVi<9Y+BWCq!2lmVccQP#~R$Mu#W~SIU;d?%sUeX~^U2fff zK+W7E*uq-{>q!NjYL-~WoJgWcK2nfoDtzw1JukV3c24I#V-I4PiLWEy#S;gRo>@k| zM-s7pV=9QkgtG$Y+NXUy^V_q66`%>H`IYpM1jsDbB9%$(nYM{TEsQt5Zx&D7ODTMdmF3L~r$p1Nsuu88 zpGsNKlAGFpW2`9at-9S3e{(_>_uZ7m^NW_kAC=l`!xm48*~u~v-f1F^JJ5LKZBn?J zL^kxo2$0Q7n(T2c?!iUyxpqz676^)7?J7fwD>kL5jU`p(){s8O-(5IiC9+?N_*o<*>@MZ)$%L-gT@CYRY+7SSH(v!-*Bq(4 zJm_C#c%SB?mFO{9jMd4dBvGGLkmifY{=+~5FlTR6%0I&9Q*Wa z@_`x?r*2?YIic1y_R!_Ix(ClW+)@g(%Y(R6*8>jnyu}VG(5vO18!B_ty-4>ahD)L_ z=xxqWLbvB_-aRG_o7B;X=B`gn+j}vxqkb}7UZ$LQf5f9acQej|>n9Izx=L^}yu`fF zcgfr*33)WRXDm&$I(LG`O?hSG?Ukl|*~bl~B2u))`P6K)E1LtJ;*d(djOjddRHFG- zi;3ObxxLly0hQNFxE$JJ#@=RBNKAmK)D3*=TBqri<^#b`*+UYsuW##y&xi ze`kNmMtNz)MW#Gj-&Mitr0qLmfg!Uo3|rT-GZXuwm4T;X0E+20QSG#{4bDx`DO2Jo zy1PQPCoUs-$7`&+_MGc0#E^dcl@uqadv08Jd9FWO6UIVAX??T*&crcKpL{9jp|;ck1qS?1m+(nGm*ONwJ$zwJdDGh^`n?cZUfld$WaeIb z(*)mo0&_u*FcP0nW|w`f#ARLEkY8PJgS5b(Bwf3G`k%@Di1#V8n*TTaK9|ZN-uiM{II3>Zb%q1YO$Eh{r*$TP( zYf<$52aiRH8_)O1rudG?%@Kk!b2hu(Bq z4iq1nJbvogY-pWHjUu~M-ed_2-jqJo|H_rRg~OFPaMi43N!}fjWdTbC?6JibM$)#s z;yPF=T*TbF{7xA7Nt5_7wne_jvjkd=n`ro=_kO-R$=M)%u3D#2sh(|mJ(PiuJ%mw< z#p#(Y`$mb1%fQUx;;C_T=*bxzJk+IgpyZl}%92Uo0oZfon6-F;F3yVAHHKfSHCiW1 zEx@Ta`o2&`rpk=AW~p^FERCXhuf#PK6yNIdQj;FVaJx)OO1r32+b+S+i7rN5?Sj#p zwtjZYzTCQ&8;ith{czSu%7Qt#q#$p$|79P(_0{+R^NxtHB8u0?YMT|FzZ;M_L7OS= z_vT|XwZ;w^9q83{xU+?lM$D&9o5)R;xQ)qZ&Q(E`gedcBn#p97nA0?OpAQ=`d0y!5 zq)|yQP?n2VG-G1o3La;ZT8}^Ob35XRUFma*XHy2xm>u5Jr6ulZfag5VgH!}{U>cFLgJ5@O zV9OJ#3?x)F-bRK=1}5V;QRXfdyQQYjgcmiU0%{3Fj@5UC%x-dCWLx5mulOQGOvLJg z?yG)kTFot`C-cj^cF48TCXG_Q#R|~CN%OD@PP`R8{*nX~x%6uvb*HYYf zf{Vm;5Vd;c32dD8_WkzSxf7M{q=Su$c&`=LTf)ml*0E*qTpC1QTp3^UYxDh?;h*-= zM8#B&+VX#By$>_FPE5`COe;s@6o7Gz-mj`7a^c-qp{qFq4~FXs5}rp`@xc; z7;3MDX!yD)UW$=Fpq6l%ExoCWh#DD>-rXe8`@SlhMda2ln&}P$`I@kO*BwikoKGE(}nir_)J6?EASX@p%Hl#D!v}H!DZC- zAB=J7&ZfGZqUoQCig9(Y?1BalxZZE&Q)|xWwtsDd{Ahh~W_0DC%ClOkeE*7Em-jo? zqCR#t$ezp}#(WsyZB$uje%kXg?qeIvVerQ#Xa+yO-|+!DW{H7D!y5%?(pC9 zW@yyq;SHLiv@RJ@hl&NVp(NqJc|M+pD}~E5xdX0B-Rl*H53Q;Xgd<79Z=Bj*_CB19 z|1ugwr4?7^#P@EzoX{s}U2i0P)W%MiRO%dcTz5^M_1W#_yY&0syB$>)^-6gD%Bs1G z&h?_(eqYT^YM$H?AuUGZ!J$IkrR%bTJ!`z?{bb(1$o^liju0r^ud>&diB;jFU%-Vy zmjzb@h&-w#5)MmaWt17B`r3iFkb*r-!D{sI2#F}qz^vR8%kg2BGy>Fu+vR>K<4RO&#LY^hhwW-n~KEH=)}C3TU=vt z7K0kz;Wob%=*^rm!amE+oa%U%W6bXB2F;iA=KOz35CPub{mYI=;(p!na)w%jR)yU| zv#cksJYCN0_A@*_QvcDzRoSpetUeOn20POce|tvDlG!t?z2;<@g=|59q=k99U&NiL zm_zcnhEw10-LfQ0R${r;R_G9y#8e6&7eBeWu5>YsCSG^>DqYhV+?Oe6(Ea`jhS~`^ zgkpu@OHrjZf&oVcvmz6IHi4}$Pye!6)0n}Vg*61Vi$`=moh{euo@#0(clDN?uM~Eu zEG8ej9v|x{$a0Tu#LHgemN0H37;#vA zN{;RgAXAGKp;nStdX881(3wX1F@L~)QeU6#bK?t_CiJaD&hR2z5zJlIS~%;gsZ(m> zLuTGgW!$%GyU4-3DSbrk>V?3E@AbZrhs+;)*OPYVD9q?6F5h7+Q>|=iLC9Z<5j~wF zUU4v^UKM#CzmKVJt@$D4!Ox`neW+`${MDxXnKx}zVlKFO$=#*u(_U)D^)<6Jxh-Al zyLtnO6ypndQ5WvApx{&0@Q!%v@)6`*j{9HM^yi!0|7DSW-xWFr8W$*G^nexLRNyH0*Cs=tQ?KG&(sLnP4)Gd z;vQPs7kWZT=RbUn*@puzsAv-3gLJ`!MxhqVU-l zJ;$;xK0D={pmAJuIFH%yE2E=Oe4*bH+e>S7wjTv#|AG?yKJYIn5oqkMFcY*$RFK^& zYuO})oJF%sVSe?U~3OQCiTI64-@#m``Y2!#=_vRN$9#MzQzlak2?DAcd zO50yHB;YUv93p|jAR%xmV4>j%Boh3@@xOKy5=RR)^0pyweezNDAi014{PX>*%g;g6 z6aob^f??3dAI>18FgvSAjp71c0uVaEC~HMKWbM-(Z0~3T{(=?!4)h)C{{n+W{<`YX zcNiLByH)%Ptf>NpKFAv+H;vw7*msCfD?B21f_qQ8C;{25yepetJlxVVc=aNT?u43t z?4`wA{PTuaR59-h4Bsv7P0n5{oeW=~*r{~T;V;m@Z%qFJ4UUHWf=x~j$Jh*`ANoui z2nq5wy)~M|KNtVy?De@T+*C|gd>`J(wWVf+2WvdwicGEM{e+595I>h8a9XJqCQig? z1fN$l)-aK`$kOJ!Nqtg%y^mFvQ^zhO`#}VEZBqLj<&vRArS}}g>wU)sEvx8lE3elP z$7(bt`NuDE>8$M*M4d3`fI%VGkYm zhyh?vc_|}=j;g2ohOFL&E9c2yT@PKOrcZ;l3lHu;mk_P2ZM~RgJ8|fk-gS9FftorE z+`b}xDJnfDZF*!@p4NEEe1pAgjW6zcFZHGPha+b0C>4&!vf;Vc7TI(+pwNEiy_J}BRF%uA9^Sq@hCp3Hc=wXUqyTx-Xhx)vQ+Yxhi9X-v%QL@4LW#g@8J)Pe8v90MtRLef&)`gU*%i9B&Z|;RC|J~rZ1Prj&CIHcV0_#e^z$7LR+Rd zuY$`>&+DX+mAT_>X`XJH_77zPOon%MvWDG8c6m*RJTq3U-tU7^cRAta5&PLxvnPyj zLiK_`{N*Bk*(-VNokFyeaalYhF-rWaj50Eb^SI}=>`ruMR1H$YVWC02GQG*q5?l3! z-pJvmpKv!Rr?+VLQl+C-PYo3dluTd@%h~|DaFlZn~qlWJu>K3h4$Y0j$ zdRJT=)d0k3EO*(oVb)WkP_w664ZVkk@|&kEc-Ib9Dvidy&ge93UE5#9+AUG8*3DES zK}%)8B4?ToW#jMdUY(OJBx+s`HrZXn%2|I-W5+p{b>Kc23DKWbXuD&BFr*9-9Po1X z+#N|0iaeWFpFJjgJ@4wOoLTy#u_Ueh9&R1oIf~YfR*fr`8XH&A(==5QQy0!uDy@b$ zCd$gI!P|otF_G>$)Izg7`G-1NSfwi-?5ualcz%4&x{2q!XtW7kRUwbtiUmtb9{2Sr zjzQSyBbbrR)rkt~-j_D^A#Y};(B(}LuMLtcn~85OK0dYkiPIO({T<`BY>7c?*D9GA zoUx4&joBx$tta2H;20YtY%gVq)7v@;T{|5c+1Qg^m5*Z7mvygj|jGvJxF zr!%Rqg5IHY@26Rld&x;b zW>rm7@$m%XgGlCBRG2znSaD`v7nLG&beU=lhQ#_Y9~wsvKOR#EU-Xi2x9Zlxy7nxZ zmaa@E^H_RH3Lk)$a;?6{P#!RFE?rSjZ~RQy``+tD(wMK-Y}fv0Q~rU*@_-71Bby*gbGi6(aTc4q*CCccGws|e z#Yd~xUwfS6sXH6aCFM3Am7L*Ctm&rG6!fAf9tmA10eN;yDJ%+InoqoCk?19F=VEQ@m z`Cq{V0{-jy4{d;Bq~xPtTmx==1f!w8dO0GGzubEq{lu8({)zDFWWMwj!=ysK86)}A z>5^G>!~LBusM(9v5?(>Ix9XwS6B{EPBF^1+POGKJkfl)We^O|me1NB?H{VF4Vwg() zLJeW>i0#eb)LVSBkq{dZ4spfDMMqioyLSucq3@lH;v7wVJ@U{fzwIJ>@Gc5tELZR%VhHl#bvc)7ypzG!1a%aMhWj_zm=E+RnjpqP%%ENV()@C_BO&3ynqBB zCp-yE%>lAzzGd1RB>?FwVCIdiEG<;U*}=gc$c+J$VJsj(!VJ`lh_?mueP9qM5lotK zvv&Z}c(xu%&W=uG2nq{K%gE3API(i$^(K1x;X$DHNbyoAA4G;m$NSfje$Vz zw>n^?02B}$@E;Fk?!W;uP~jj@cL*F{0}22G`~%b%sDNQk1Gj$PQj`9}3HS~mx+Qs$ zL0$m9p&+yWf6*||M8)3AmgGz%dypXTt^6fm7=WyUCzAkxK#q_k41fa~&mT`fAgzu6 zHWLC3z|+OM16=+g*q`EQFp&!RJ)quR2NP#IvJ=4AcBT}7|ND*S&uXpcWeesc;Shi< zl<`FMZD|4Qfw;jp5(p$9L?GqJ(F<6aZSeoV_Wvhh4ItIa*;bL@=w=T}Q3vn4g%f~@ z0wixlws$uM>D!56AR|8s5Ni4#zMt6nZaFL<7#QsTMWOw_9R~^cHWaX$C=3jOMPeZs zB!(6TMDtQu7z81Oh9GgUt%3${g73lhNDO?tMoNM0|5u^?{vHXm1q(RF_ku>k0gVO) zfJFfX7zl@jNJ#;|f&GLACYJ&Wut^X&G%Zjd7+`at(ZC?U8BPk=Pf}O_01S8rYw$gA zjg0{k-=u*4;FvhTHDIvYG_c-c1}Q}g)*uLwDX?Gwg#-Jd0miq-0NMicZao9BF+vKv zRnStntr{l<;05RyI09gBdtMYUFB&*tB5`0p6a)>_SU^}{y;TrkJIt04z#5!?YtcXf z0vG_n(t>lMfj(P8`3?@Ow=@l$2?hRufg%E7gRFryP`1_uoNl|&q5&4SdV=!(@c;na z9s&Vy488$T0m#3r!T06*UIR-;`yI#@DwGr)WP1xfs0Y751$o+1CP1OUUjK~(f`Y+l zx88jl0EfXrz86ptwsip1gI~**tO30Mb>gS8r4OJ^d@ozN@=Yf|efYV6xVC-+V}QEx zy?~r!U}#_s0j!`7{H5Tqz?y)10odH1%XgjlUV}mb)}3~%2A_W_TWh`j9&Gbp0rdi0 zRj~f?(dOqvw=!^70oWG9Eg$eL=@M`Q-|{xME#KCiFVF(?Awb^dcJnQ_0yu`P6jOHy zu-sdtfUXBv@~!6|ZVIvG;ePQ}TW4cnP$2DfYuat+1en~duG_wDD}DyrfUXQ!!L2vG zpfB8dIt{4$wkUu&URq50B9X33czJtt;Srzl|XJlgxZc_71dwy}{4|mgUQ{@xBD^_OPzWrb=)cln2-qJq6at9Lert!r0!I9I8V1}fzmA8416KK08XSfNoYb#07z+89 zc`<*;6o$g#{+JiArGH>XO99UHw>dDt%zw}jfMff;9bh2;ph-#nAp;B!-1y+%4>?Q0 zfk^Oo8WM1#ztjGL4+~t<{@xCY0G!5eeX(fV?|J~kN}>PY1B-+Gjt>q;0l~w6^t zXE%G&R>r>u!2vK?;64QGo1upXxP7;tjhs*01IiC>2rn|8MBdsCKs=6t(H=T