From 95785f9df532367ece2830e8b7c27c18f21bd087 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: "Edgar P. Burkhart" Date: Tue, 7 Jun 2022 11:41:48 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Results from swash 1 --- nature/fig/maxw.pdf | Bin 0 -> 14909 bytes nature/fig/out_orbitals.pdf | Bin 0 -> 10440 bytes nature/fig/ts.pdf | Bin 0 -> 13682 bytes nature/main.tex | 34 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 34 insertions(+) create mode 100644 nature/fig/maxw.pdf create mode 100644 nature/fig/out_orbitals.pdf create mode 100644 nature/fig/ts.pdf diff --git a/nature/fig/maxw.pdf b/nature/fig/maxw.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..07c2bd4feb0e891eb4b1570241727749bb7fb285 GIT binary patch literal 14909 zcmb`u2Rzl^8#rzzgzOcr$R2mN*S!(4_a-x&>~(F5ip;V%nW5~Nk(3d#w<2Y)kjzwm z@2mQJTL16=^ZLDh*Xua%_wzpES?4^@Ip;YS)TL$lAp$}~7mBAqj~a*|ATY?;+>S_8 z6eOr_W@F_Jf&vgtkf64Yixo&v$_#Dh;A{gD6C<*6vcwcb{!~H68!e}WHbYy1guYdh zb#_97VBenA&CqBoHzyDr^GYPB?&fTvWrYSA0{uwK0_|IQqd|fSjzFK1-*c(&xdO-- zB&c=G%+l7$288%lT~E#2&dLG}5w07y{Q0br4|m4&k?65dT_zoV?gnGWasNb8h#=jR5b1kF62?`imqc zN2~9$@4mLn-=R^gPcRr8dKEBb&}TcZ^=Vi@rOLKfyLz#{O~%3S390iWsKCQMpbxof zwETLzBq@DWkH3FwQ~dS~Lh(Da_ieaSS~qWf!6WUC4RiC`tm{7By*Dfl&LrLG)3nVWHSbF( zalWMnZ}Q*WYOj0OF8(0e{9v!&Gk)gl%Dcv`H0|=$x_9^9y`B;O+*(IwlIDBt*Q``O z^+}Iyae6}K)8HGw&G7zDg6*!1u!XDkHPK(s67;F9v^*0Z7m{sA_EQvp6SQgg!H1yM zm$7Ec=I&#$&LDV)+OouIcgYLrTKg2x1gSsJ#6|E6G-Ji69yBB%3-@CI+O&-C_1NgE z#;v*O{m;JrB4vGso4I#I3ximen|xj0Fuz1u{Px|Jq;_z$i}xdEy3(Kn^<%NuGYFhN_%+uYCtWweGk1Ix^=L-z!;4P=CR;m4 zR!>aES#oMg4+8|wn7HOh`;?luz2@YbX1w`8d)w>7huLP8uN7Y#`Ft*JHO#`8mBR*l zQGGQO8`tZI1<8*Hjpex`B{nrOA8*Cqs3zXOAWVBz*S{}V+gM#X?-DgCTPcZ3AI1{T)p5PJ)NvIV zx|H}y@NMg(W5_|Y(|ebp(PO{fmw8iM)3c5mE7q+fkfBC<;Tx<>Vedlg5jj0M0bE3e zO$k&sNh&J1EiE=2S6z2S9m*B6D$Qrnk8%m8&pW0ouEkno=^9|k_$A*9;jw%bDq-IC zMOI$W^RkgsReW*-H-$~kJB6t&pQuM6G8y`CYQN-_`rbiBy&)$;%JcBXns*QDLV5YK z89X`9&cq5^XG&uY2@t4FWp%%yWKh&|wpWp`NuJZaBG8`q${}H@RoXoi)939=}JNdhz-cmv6pdsz<_xX6>>i$0@l7^Vf!a9>q-v+WFK+(pj~Gd#z2} zQf38JlgtMtyv{#ScWyX`>Qcn1B#p?D>5nIkyQJCEtA--2jq9Skl30uPN}(lH1e+VO zm(;_3z9Y!W(?{|;KR3yuQb&*|r`*zPUuao)(Bre*%{y7Aha$szm1pb1^aW0Z&yv2b zs6q6)A4K?b))i}2>?<4K-O-s9x{r3_J^dkEC`CjCSUvj=!Oe!+ zBh_FnhbcbW>BM%z1)7UxucwPkRy?c3+hCM}#OUmrL z`hW;$0x9YqU$H60m=HL?^)4&4fs9tT`^LrjTj9dz3{7v|XYi5X%_3#xV7C_BFr3%E zLGe0%-G5LjaVO8*jMr^SZKFQ%6YDrvuA3(PUSIUGUx2LRqsrkSGwqm?&%%b~LR3}8 z5%K-$_#W}43oD#n>Pg770clqD&s>njcU39Lo2Y@S4;}UNow0GP)mw*eTQchAC{x$o zepskFy^D3vgJ-&s;ZDS-(2R4TQrhRm%Z=dpaalZ-d-AX?1xg3xk7izI|=3bphTLqM?0BbN>a(S~Ep6$60g1_v6B0>ErmU z(~Nc-5Ax|=l@`{}$S6EyuGXGQ`QTTlsC#HBrcRrxqzY0Acbkr;@+ua!Roxk*qhFYkkRGyY zdc&r}##!ov9AYGeykWsfO-!7`Du@VTkD_S}!5WHHzJztUm%<(==7l(|v%FSqU~<~4 z@vP^5FVY`el@mWFTl~_Df(!?5OP$)qwth3QL|H&z%}^pnuEJF8*|Q3FpbW)C&PAM5 zE-k7DXj-5kYy z)l;iv9?xey&uirLzuJv17tl;|QI%X1EgM*0h$h<=C8?2qS8Xm(pKiL`M#QmXl`XTQ zp83%0$tg`NvxOeZO72PO}mp^DxuB&+MqIr72;`dA16dv zNh0jpewJbwzCsRqeJY+%01ki>N$=4(x{tKpqqnj#V?@^ zL~MnX9jz3KrI%4H9F8$ONK)=+=BGGn!mP9SZBkTLt!XKxnq_s4RJzT^vRaCzUZp^{ zLUgwEQzKCGV}$Xf=W_WCu4$>1Xt?YcYs7k3Qbas{wCc=b(Q}6x3ZjhG$JLI0b?f#P zlE0z&8GQ5|Xt$Gwn{GH*Yvk^7cGoWNgPK#exbL|V1E{I+_6j%8a#l~ljr!0%Th?IP z&MY4;sllQa601i>QxBqYW7(8XEk68o0a%3v!+4Jp#z)G>H<$em-ceM1ud7FG+vBE`dJYU+PC)}c4*zF%U5~mnftkbVaVx@ z2X~(#i4d=|kUf~r;56JZWvv`*si*SUSaA-UvIRVyjb)IQoTJ=eTqdU7d?B^9z;nCj zY@1$}HCC7_ZM|ZE<7|k*$5u*Fs_o@fJM;+KMkBX;i@b8vLHT{^#2k@S36ce_agR_D zeCl%-T(fr$hIbUg%|{u|Z#7w?FW6>SGRVX|ubL{E0P!h{*b+Hp#Y~n4-4%aK*SOq2 z9Mv=voqeM$FV=a&p@;3OUP(05wAXqn$ud78GM1cKk8?@ZO#A+|{!lWWjZMn}>6w`4 zWKVBz;)D}WToHeLd`xG4FziS7s5?lvd{L_-d}od3i-<*n&V%%Olk~i*Pql6GygC$< zUov*d>cQKUD|o6Yb$1Mj^4ix`_4JKMc-K{ghzNwD%5&7}`>B1~138``V5$a!7mK(} z6$Zgfp4LPy5_+U*Tn(~V<^c>1SSbvNqYN+S_jh+VDijm4(@6| z&PaOon%`D|qqZyn6)^OOmwDU9J*)A|_PTZ$E_@P8^TORRVWfDL z6Zv{qgI+|Jp7w4ut7p#=1p%h?%b zqG=^!7&exz=?midNjjx@9vFFLH?}oj)DMPO=S`gfXO}A29eJGVfbexNyH5{=-nn3` zeoIh4TLc9T*BA=xyc>s0S#1{VCQn9sh8sT6xR-$&=RyPvCMH1O37zt|XoLjU;^OeJ z^r(?KEE}_OeC4!ET2EGHLCmEWk7>u3%u)_^*%9W`rZ3pvFHQt6KGSh7rpe4zv>xA7 zwPVe%DVsAp%)Ovk+i~X9>{M&;`p~>c+hz#wqjp>@-}?cGPl~8i_AcD3nW$9hJR zW>y5LxYSLstDYpxfK6kz+NMR}H4$u@Bj6#=vs9+MYa9A7996_jFZ)l6i=K-J!Feu5U#=}u?igX5jFpCac-qtsksF$$ z_1q%@3=a5^`%15t=WNrIuvcQ#5IrHKI9JSF39_kdKAhuXPQJ9{`QTTomeYsTV@`Jb zsxi|mLP3(N@mk`H84nm~tW^qDRV7uVOjRJvUgWDu@<*JHAaM7j zu+y)pMcOow+c89j-lHy!G|+f>@qQ(_-8@N)!=(!&%Y2g8*o+9_39hL%wol0Ia)gvV zx=)>kH%^U+s9lkDEOM{D#WozF7ih%D7j$94n}ID@Db?34x1GtnnEarcxa@h}5_vPs zPNQ&iaUx2cZCc*GY)`~>485jv=S81vI-z*nmA)ybwiN3cb}&n6o4zn}+ZA!2st1QS zUiEi5ojJU$;P>C+(UU(A9$ZFBY_1lklhCk7YJH01?(O1d!|gJN`jXyB{+83R!%Z}u zj3MG-9&aPXdX6)n*La4?+I3zAmVAP=2aMLT$~Nt47faSk9tvg1imeDaIQ!O*Q~Tr% zH@wwA@$@PbteB4@6^to5eAm%Q zYyJt-snYL5?ROMo>u~)Q5VV!>4{|p+?8s$&D)?rf8)un zlQfh4a%Nl38SuM1rd+sVl{mk99=(vZlP6>xg*{f94)x)=# z8nry6MjxLOMsVsB*iWnnFvQ=kpO^!uT=S^i?3-CBC8A`)P5(TtNw=tD^dzpiYB0z9 zaAu-0#}>q5>}atmR5onmKlWxqWIEhsbwT56=bIHxiMl#Oh4XsG2a=ITa)%jDA{s<( zUyh?DMLfcMr{d&EW!o1``3pte#5Gj8+CjWd1-(a|Oi^W;VnYR|t)5;Xe>AT1^o-@; z)b@^!s;(NGtM^uH8;U6M!3vJy5<27q`w?17Rl)e3;vONP&W&Mv&Z7~^)ZC+tbtz8M z<|-}DNlsrRi{Mjc%NcOn`?j8p5h?g+i^Zr&Q2~08w?KdJu2UAn45X0y9Nl|^LPh7UJFN~jPh-)BC>Nx*d-DyHeiNf4Us(^%*74l73U z`Ccxa8Nz)X<>YZ4dyw(Qw8{fzKU+zdWz^xoy|-Bv>U!%c;rf@h5Khr= zO}F;Bu>4m>v(0H|7+TW_#ki$-tN8T^sjLcL&#!yo4VDEW&TDw#?RpO;-kMFL!e_JO zYMv%sk29fKroHR+X;W3uP6(g1Os;k-My6-aN%8~iwVpIznv8?Th zIzovJ#pp-b(Ipv$vk+_*Yo2QA9ez55MrhK)HA3aKig6YEZDSnTZpvTc2_twZt6@%~ zByA$;{KRr_-&|D2H_F9IV0TDPwEI(s5e*2vosG5;kYU-Gw0R6o^8LbpXn&5;eKIoB z>kDGB5=I)jOn7Bc(?X?WG^rVuWLyPmue*~`KVoNDYC=y4@sR8f)YU;>_6?rA_ z_+g#HXHtt?E}a{NacU_qRr~|O)Hh#b2%c?Tn{IobME>SOgiZ0MS`*X8=I(=eVwMl~ zE=dJ-9+}3+?Mv-5aU;BezE`$sVWT&))u!gYs0?$5>+T*U^soDf#T*S}-aU%Y5?J|S z`^33nho@g)RDG_$*?(d|mY=y{!;PtUC1yzTC(vZq1MK$L)E;IQt(PkX1UQB4#eU| zM{^v>n6oTwL39&W{WA&@ec2>T+@61(7A*d{aU{(8zU)!Mr%m(i8Cy-tflxbl+Bnq@ z?Rmxy9QCM~=}qD{R*BbzRZMzVOm&-^f{(UlxE(i?FuT&ERLNM@; zP3w~#VGPg^Wc&{dvz7c`wrZg;IA(+QpM6@mhJq6o zeQU848W9?Gl{Qz;d7)dELv4-ZUao+LMVATd#pqlu3iM0O<=3V)pEQqe-{h z89B#wYj*GMOx4X?p{Bjd!@E!XF3UM_Sn|}V%kpFv3w1L!GPXq=`mL?s8ssE}EyOPkP@8Y$_)qr88tZemuim!4ShuW! zq9s76JiPyiFMnFVn{=Eb({PVmylEhdc?2#%D2%?6YsD>O@$l%zkl*J>=vzBwV+YMg zek`I_rFE8<3FN}gTO`pg&0Qv3QG9;QAT+^C2KVyDc6GNO;l}GXcAb?3Mag|4+}7o5 zXiWhp+B>Ywo!f<53%L{alKlteycc%lCqiIuoEz6V7DqZ~qrbk1!c)3edX4qt+cKvy z0n;X}i!$bxs&2)$5jv{->Quw^txwLJ-F1+W;&zW2T{UU#BeqX;pz&7xgwLEi&7nl9 zJNdd$b+bfta$ujuU>wcz7vBHZqXii1SAD&tspQlyar*TVl~LBvR$9N0rp|QJk+Z#& zW)V+Q7^DLn&>daBpkz$p8r)TPwbW4bfxm#EL5fdkV?@*ivD&Gm4c1y?v_J)tNp71M zn!zJo*!yrW`#>@=m>^npE1URv0P5?UVBoXya+1gIEb~tI!r&3%dH(QFK zF3eNEum5~TV`FU}if`u}nNMtSZilcMU(!*&4QEvXOL{$CyCnLq4Ljvi>S-JEbEZp! zmDr{9+R}-B>n}o!`U)ePq}#;QR6cPfD)Z}hIBC(Fe2$MC@kitH6bWs|Zx85H4G`;v z`B3bkKFc30jXAJ}Tyz@S4qIS>wL>ZTOqEck*-3M9Z(r+ske4#mKkh>Zu_TPSC|9pt z@7z`Uihga->(S(PI!9tbb|X{l^QTN_j?BZ}KMhp(I=wMiEC%SMVjv8yFeD1KBF_v8kgYmH5eAN(Qwklo>Vjx!g0Z8fH~-s1nbqfrUI!HsioubZqi^B9${H* zTw<~wF&X4G3*V)K7*==TFO1i7CL8sAW4k7glb6nGX&h)43Ybe8hcfnOlW$$hwx`gq zc=7?omz(0=Ou!QS7!Q_>Z4saVtuI_mV5L+&<8hAEAn*BOd-K*=gF(@#DW@Y@Yb%c1 zB=;;Or|1GhL2EdbbbRp$1SM3z5BEJu7m0!CcoCyU#7*A#F+y~XZrj72w^fT{p2AZ6 z+iwd4K76{Sn`9b1sI;r+Z4xY&T$JLu5i9BYPDSK=4>M67RD_?m#;~ zUHb=2Wn{gdjneTkM4 zx^WwyxYkFO1wVn~DzzSgqQ#W@J&7mp-1xhu@X1^_Z@e1NPEQ>6vW-#D;hxH)@Hr;6 z;fOBu8MMgQC$>0Z6a5R8nA5)hBxgACS2Sak-0(oBrS~&$vITyg7mZW2g47=)Nct=h zo=JsYZY#1qpx|4g@&N~QZTDK%u6UtzMHum^WVn*Mbe1b{9*JnRrPznrtyx&jKOPo2 z)y~*wj4HBp&5iWX_TX_*?oZg&m_GE>j}MR|wIZ4*c0cFvw%f6lj#Dm|ND_&GE;P_m7k2pH2Q8R0ymEM!19jU;~^~Sk3{}|!4-2X{sY(li3}9_i`d~BjgIZ$GwX1CS}^GPh2A-kd`#Vq zG?7rDDo#pglpR7TjLV|(nGu3kHqeMM(9FmCOl1b`W-Dz&U z$Bzy?+3N`i-5~nQTBI`J+;uJf^n8;s2I*^V`b5W00XPh1!N~Qh2_S65{ao*~GUfxw8sv|e`X%UZ}sVvo&^>>3xBQn)ygsIjsfNHdA*qLSvDEA=n> zvo60mfQj08-Bl+|RX@EmjRU$f-6DHitfs$30Jm15(aS>dFx`^784p3USE$9*y=A`M zqw75J`NeX#wT44+Wwv2u?U689RlqT}3B8}?UqpckL-;SEK*D~J zgiK^3NelS2wBG|$yz3l$VjA(!-#jHbd%@{3=kz5bCc+eMCs?c0smwEcA;zvjJBeUo zBRTcE8SA-bqs^;$QM(T`KW>u6XRa5|hOA-ZNHSRe1vN~F!+${y0tf$s+a=(@t`&Ud z^%tV+pg<43+Bb3Mm!rSlC|S;8!XwY}?yStUz$b+SDZDrrmQ>C1Stv?^?^Y_CuVg!z z&jq0nbmy|J!WA*YbY<2W{HyW@V^pGyDwa1hUxYF}j_X>+-PAO!@L0xve^!Uxxay2W zMM;CpB{MvDyD#YtKe$Uzd6a@^s)#Y=+qu9_tI zFJ1pfCDf;V!>T<{0 z>Y{oig5Q-r>Iv?bf8BX8^ksC!<5>P+KWV;sNSkQe&CN$2n3)fYd%CI!Is_-Z$awcg zZdcqkdsVJ+D{p!TQk8TPv@%h<#!%;#jQRoga_iUv?nSWd45H-M5FaG`9Q6 zj>DzC<;o%t^UBXTsJUO|Ffp*HzsTHA(6v`OL9W?|Lls;P>vMm{HLNRJP2-7>w=;5Z zzWYT_aUj^qNH&};`hL-Q(X70#9uA_}d+E$>Jh*17sikN)Mjh9J%pQ1JL>)}QdaYT$ zBIUV{F|z9G87=D?AI^TaoROl_n-w-n0|Thi%qNNZ*U)K{O?kKbJ5<$Fo3FsuSW(o3 zMdk)qp4n2Rm=nIHFwxS`O7*4xdbGXqLFD>ZY(95?_dmq~`>$S|@UP<;2196p)yu&+ z6b~MR5G~3k5^;wZNr;6eyu_z`iCxvh*Av9YMjV}ZPC$y-0_#-j zKcv(=a^ZD;>%1Y${)Gz3H}~GB_Gq^6(^OIQ^Owo>lh^SR;b~A_(n}GfK0ngGvwX48 zMe%;nmD6=pj7_%`ux{BM5HRP%KWzKMx)`Kr^z~XRA<@rIrAOv$ScHEh0G4yhLj0;OeJ&lli)Wm!CL0o@5=E<7R{}0 zZY<2f%bth6*N8K2b=gSl^*TLx?JFZq_gf3<*g(003JMZiWJ_pE=2c|-)sK`Y(w0z* zj8wie7S}imeD8*}3}ja2n{~WkHrV}0roG~S=P!czuTCK3S0C_Xq6loIk}4I#Vp_!2 z{7cI}`$YfC&wv1a(a$25xu-;m#|pTY={a{>Ua%~=LRW&_kKYGoI8j<$3f2y)znOhW zz#cb)nuV3V_CsA!;$0biF>PN>U9zsXcZxe+vQB03ZQWGh31L-_NM?xPw{ofre2pNf ztW40#zgr%W3%<8k?Lf_Jl4E$@BUb!Y8;{`BTmw^Q{#fIioQUQddDsxbzfkj^y(XdG z6&B@$2RXC$g(v_N==6GX67ZTnKP4%eq{4MYYsQNhXnVfA6Rcgcjy|kTcts&R?`0L- zM%eX;;=N{wd|{I=>*!_*w5$$pgV(8<|9n1g-nHwdcx!$E@r%RSin4`HrhCkK)NI+( zEztJ1WroDQjdE+l>xs54_q=bX^N#Vq(8JecoJPJ6-_Q2puRIm{BqcGNh)Fk$=KAFi zS#nVUdvw}*puzX&6kH<1)MElYgI>v>LHY4{YOw6UxFD3vuNY;fE(cwRO-8jhpm$~t z1}d_?PDBbny~wj-XrON~B*yqYzJm|C;;XlV{y6sH7O~J~&gZ4kGZaErQL!BaC9hB+ zIVl>t-gQ!OB)yOqtRG1;Tj>cEKZ#O3y?23mrpnL^X}ZX zE|{@M;=MC}Jbt>H;1o%O1lnLWEAl>w?@H4`%%f|qGcd@_8T>ofdB+{~<|VX23Kr_{ zY|jtAJIoWV$%H*|W94V8i^)Dma!)O{zk|@*)Qww>oLx6AyOeUdtJtXR0wt~Ts2Q6L zsdx%hpxXVCFlb3uFUc(0NtXdeaaSlgpR3T*D zo!`-?*)XD_DGPXBUA>t6^KbEg|3X#ffa!y)tgbTWP6}W_Zr8 zw`=>kwrP9XxRV58batjGbnYm!Y-#E6Gp>oLVd!6Y_+K49VZ<+^^-`n=X&~Sb?WaGN zyLO$OKr%Gw&5eBS>WD8p?62DgO$}mj>RP(y#fpaA`q@SN&!(}?Utu(;DeWFgJrj`{ z`IKa4T4kL00g|@mFF5^IFAWO$b$1D_fg;6aJ+rxXP#S#KP;G$fhl7f|6=km%>2iT=aaGdy8Z!X&n1G^WaafMlilfdOzK% zmEVy_7jz0+7kO@cd3-D3k{ZV#ni@Lt2>z0ekW%Kn=;7T5qm*j~LPJoBkq+`=JKQFb zFJM(HEK1jxIF|Pn0jU1hNtZNpw>k-R7L-)c(2&;U zmA0}o)Ai6Yb8-hlrmvZ~VS=53IOOlK%Q8+t=r1OgSyYrrP}y05CV9$a z?FBrcuen)S5eZrY!O0*&YglZ}HFhKnj@-Y0khXbJ(G*Fsx4>SEyE0`D<| z{KP;(y?^lgiJTv1-w=cVga2P7qW{}=V1Ume1V~c|0R|yqNDu;sAVLAlRbeC$XDgX350+nKyWzF2(Vuy3=An@B!B=Ic*f+I@4$f%0=QTp4AjT8 zi9(`){2L6DpAZ8RCc@+xBrrr_5&}>-OkFrY__sEIvOvEl&%g={DvUfyaADL*juHm& z1>gt>6d>?hzd}I2a9}eFhQibn0>ObC2`~$jpCl-z9O8rtm>kppiO?_%1aJTtON8kY z4%9he$`9l)`H7}sdJ@9CfH5q>pp797lLP5QE|~7VB_cRL;z>;mfB$^|5d78z6rdRM z1%nlU`42VtA+8@eATpvKh@4<0Bn-ijeS$tl4}L)vL(_>e0Sbkw^-n7pq`+XJlW*S} zKp{||9|@xf-*f<@2fwBhUITi8(TShZi9TR-;zv5smG3%%(TATC2CtKMpbd;}{74we z5nwnVLjYHd4*Vsdkbq1udI8M0Kc^o$@gv7D1&}+@Nsf8`DV@mr+jmTve-cJ7FjB?j z{~mAt>|{s*`=Y?yqIoj$f4{!+ZN7t?+>QBeI8KfufI=s>1d#Db4Mz}Q7*4M6oY)ZP z$yEN$00B}zDe|w~f}WVXU(DCZ{ts{g=(`C6uGXB?0WKPS@A{jeI$1OWePe7FAjfZI zPAnt9>616$X3@!nPV~*>fdCGCg9BC&p#J397noJPKVi%yFjHW_|4x}dW=za=Cs{!4 zzE%78`!5Cp0vK$-He3eU_+byPj|+B$gvy#C!3{=62Ia`phs9e}-(ttG}O z0n{18HNX~s!}8m`uzx!PhQYtSkQ8ux32p1_B#pTS#wC3b3Wh?#a2OaO3<1V1FBr-R z26J)~37(V#Tmde?{<}ChqaAF`L7p%HxB!F?bPbJmala@i==jek0cSTGpc3FmS$bFi zcc^}@lZ2aNjn7Px=nnYWvjH4(^B%3@RqBz_Qph695P^ZN%EurTb8e!;?Uz$^N_98&lX{vp9afA9|}1bEZG)kVUAS^jqz z#nZ& z0)ZlbrvuPuz#9D19@@>!*1^i{(1Lu=Gg7Me|Nh_WyT0i<-Qzs>a?bBQ&pG#;a|`P!sYoKE&=BFm5okdT1ObIZ z$%Nw&85t-{&(4WRfg%Bp0TgC*%7X}nDcVu(+{jK)IXMWCWI!Y?Q{6rrr6sGPDtf}y$Rs7Ma zL#?1NLuWe&7m^bcyEfcZmvEeDPle)Wlm8M2u~C7eBodiQfg<2*5-0-F5J><7zcz<9 z(ZR(|f$Rgw0QNwj5mGo55-E*BW6@YBLRwl1kHeyHI6MX^4T_*==Lrm70|WvyAX3O) zp7sDjAOt@V0zumV54hAio+>VG00K~$iW>lt649RQ03fPGBso!?p@=n@0YxZOPokYW z#3y|qRWrt+?Zo-d3*xf|=C?#L;x1|Sl<#m>rP#tGV8ICG@RXb*EUb*HzGp-Q3Tlt% zhoI=`ePemE4vUZ{+wc3Nhxyr@{@7`=`eiEZ%+lPa37dMkJHB7vb;jiS`?qC~W2nIY z8PWd!?HOd<@E2Efs$YJ}yWa7jm|T3OlX7M7)*+EO>e5?2o!l20)+-Q<{M?h|Ttl8| zGr!q|yah`OE6o~L`P)gJek}EOSf`#|N0_+y>w5?;Mg>Sqow4wBolqX;b<%Y2jB{16 zfjJcj-!AdJ)Ru7<|9#@icb|mRH zrqSl&TiMl?EU%%}C1Wbg)tqn^3%96U5gAs8y6Cg-@ELcBn_&jw-R?>FwCu9z__FM; zBPhRNMBgc_xR=_uO;0VJj9ZqW<9+DYufJtOa zQu1>uFcvn%j6I4D$=%e6LlkX!p?gtN7^Z<6KPH*B9_sySOUy znd%?xvG1SUyO+Puy;%94e&fi!6nod$m(`+=r_7H(OjaC}vs6^~>i3GP50Zepw$)cL zt2!~tLK-f1dyQ!sT14xIY)@y%|->H|EO5k=+422=L z<2A(CBL-Y^_NtQm3MJ)r9MdWo=cMX36={3bOr?z<5^T?+ZizKr7Iq{x9im=7B&s-T)U+KixEWx!Na5S+E@^qU@cLzwZm-3&LF&6 zjfHAyPIKnozF4}?PoH{}=2U!2t&mHbwDRGRPGgda$<^1DJGNyPzD-0Rt$a|%f_sz8 z_%uei(ovABdrX>;uUvWTkftQYMz#_8MK_=A-i64RltMC5J+iF>bDPAVrMC2@(6Tzp zGxR;3ReP4b{EJExjv!IhGL1&@=;-1+@2xFO%@rCcsZT%n6$w@8+&cLZc0G!7y8vYh z&ABJ`O>^8QB1S#u!1lddMjG|6DpQk?5b3I;p9@uAVL#-by%zkXD7`${-LrX0kgu7l z-p-aV?9YNz9@j!zB^N-e6MLeMK7bBbVzr64o_kFmd-zhMs%3xvftUvtC$1n2ck)Vb zTbJ%{tTjzPED$o+o5S%ApME_yOk*#5(Tys8HGdNYrt$*^DN_ocIJpF(c&tYH)g%kU z(uSKduV1@;rO8ChIO&5)vO(Urp-?`fl!M%2+}+Plh0fAhUZ;2vhx#~)9p{|xK0601 zRN2kKPf^{Kcq`C#fFjPwI!4${5YDcOjj9(Y4;x~5ctlmzQnlDZE5N-N!xbWo297B6v+?8D{ zPegH>n)SpcJvMWmxO*vLI^aHwYiPNFmBlFKl;qrHc%x8kgqB`j@>o_3+ zdYEoge?vDy-9e*Lh(MA|6P>@lyDj%AM!b2^>icM_k>s-YOxxx5;gZpO0rMh`h19 z#>MB9@`o>Sgz$W7LVea_BBUG)$_YYfzvd41L8x_5Vm1lN^ zzO_sC^G|cuC#boVMj7xOsKv%9`s*um*A@&p?1-5mRcXA$=0{{s#O;i{^GIh|GxD&g zyqJdcnI1{y3*D6p9SJIpJzqa=i}&C@TP`=gEPeHquYVZ1&)l-Y!?mO!A6jrl>EMa} zgJIcGm>i1ZC$Usi=uY@GryVa*NLJhd)q_!5b(j3!U2HUUx38!)n_(Aa+6U+Fwh^fe zMs1JQsQ$FuZwD;4!0IaBRrNOSiM5bqcB!QiL;@H<4#pbDsKu$`p&trgej@sezQY4_|D?htVg@LXA2Mn z^Wodjm`;G?K7yv$EoqL+ zytWa}9OJLq`!DZ8gc}g82&|avisP9Q7oU}|@1XK|7VexazduNlR67>q$bkqyHelMx zikMB_8Si*-YjpPLlPfRz=tdI5JkOO721TA<6);CL=N*)upZwx%wDk?2hioXdWd8Y` zgGUs_W;FvMxaW+XrRme%eBfBLcQwyKqr7<&#boH+fLXb7x{Bmece=g`>6fxq&q4@8 z7tSX!+gDwEDaE9IwSd>NMQ6)X_-Dr+QR%31L6KbD=~oe1GP3hKwjoo<)kc9FeMP3E zUImSBxDj*0P{=HXu2tEgKKQ5x&r!bpnZpfF4fi>GmPHx)9CD3ojvG22b|59w=D?}2 zQFSeIX5-sQbWI1$2fYZm;ps+|d~BHZv3z&ogeDow4ukmD*4l^kF2{14&su-qJ$jFc ze6^#zjsr8qWyjTg()=Ca%7<5~44;Zp@2c0;EmoP@7aX#bKY+&D{X;f=v_SnpI8|QoG!}WyM&u4@ZdFS4E;)m?3 zLfn&jPw|FdG#ajFDt#hmSBiJl6W@2^J#;+#z|(uq{iW}yRILJX*~o;S_a5nRQMC6v zv$BS>S4K6&wSve>xR;JL`19o0e8YS$L_b==ww&8pqO)9UOOIFV++)rJ(}!4?Ws|@% zOCMdxl*m3;o|jC|QJ!HGN|@UaPSHfvY=?HXfT61!CU#D!RN@dqb^h|~CQUX)pPp(@ z#hyNj;s=ILE`CIensD{mnA+nE#w+?v9|c$vC=Y5Benp6r&1#3 zZne9WTn?&ePh`uM`-PDe-y<$r*1KEhaQ3tLTJ)diB*d#mSTf+HqT^_jd zIU_hYDnp~n=QXxFC_lUKZA>=Iwe-BP?vP2b1)YMRWB}4%1JPu$e{480Y?mRdaut%1 zFA$Ls%n;=fJ3Flqee3I%`y~ud+MM;x55!n=obEkpI#eVD)l1AB?aL~vZ$%TWZ?_0v zW%cvT=Z&Y^W@XjVqDbYDMi^uUPt}$(&O%2QB&>u_uY%HE495h_~t{zE$RI&hTd{SRb>=e%?Rzc=X}yLhx13po9K(O^+Hv>AA(w=@rCMZg!!k+*q(_y}es0}2?@Hb={G=Tfv`rr8bU;(WId97Bh2x&% zL&vxqE*JW~zhgx2~FC$^_PpT z=1Fk9^}0v2&?ws0Zif0$Wa6}W-)*-{di{=`xF*)x^U;&A>B=gXvt!bu9v=f|Sn8Z6 zmy1}$B~*ouvhk9q4fc^PnJ;)$mlNnmvQLKV_eq`5yiy`NslHe5ysB=l(|kRzn{}On z;^7L>-c8KmuP?%*80#&mYL;_$91Y^55)6tre0}ePFFfrpBXC76dZ8($>JwJ zf1aA0qUF@nCSTpXUup2}HMX4MoeJheJnwCBhA7cha$m+Qo_$2kpcpjAyYpR7cgZQn zU#f{Hx4-VH!c7pR07`IP8mfeJ~O=y+<3(H6^TVo0t4N zQ&+TPZ?|ThXXN`_k(gyxL+i!JWFrYjL&NxP_8yX4s**R%J=nm^0TdG*h6(8$tW5_Mu*T2BE z6PLPR)wF#+@#O@;sU?GcCby4yS$(#0G;$mH!m8hBPIQNlCsg)_sIH%X57BfM6&pdX7+>&$T zYkl3Q${jU#+PzZTN{Qv`Nj)p2?436d3y_tS{O{9W-oc*BtSly<;VqAO+vO{kwOxCgaCJ%?k6+0sbEvfl zA9C&!Gx+H$Z@5#kyKCi@N$gX@`y1VS-|1o!>;BHVmzmKc__{_aYSg$VT zYehX*!i!f+XWKER19^MDg|^EzP2!Gz(6#maW+8oPfG0wJm;At}$&mHT>6`E9r>xD2 zPs}6rU>0&sBQG;LnpgJ0h|c9aK{ny?1CzMDHjx1ZAG>Cb(U-`nq{!B@Auq|TUK?mF zNO&{ACR@^1C_a2AO#Z3&;ND`llh;0WdHcQ}X=^3kXxq!Fc>F-;BC4|X#K7I4g${pj zm)i?78q4jEYaja%@9;$Nm0oE?a$da5nZ7u~cKMrA7fx;B2N$mBQcA{ynEf-Je?A9$DF0n>EUne#c!185N$x7Wi>reM57>7c5w5HfCfEzo!4O~YVIyDSG1o)_oIFjIC3MfLHr*Um zXFr!bX6+sLkmnvzo(aWQmu%dXeJ_FGzA{!;h6VXVc=sWA?KZC`jzi(~{9|Q;2AwKN zeS@s?y$82EFsyv>I*`@9;2UMBaF_ei5Sxy--y8LpY+=($g$=|Bj)YdzZL<2+nuyb} zZ`?9PGwZ}Mg52behbbkCIgN%lHi|uBnyG&0G=7ZV+3H!YyM3ODMqA%qMs4l*9bc7p zI#r@)IlrIjzEeNA#H_<_#PScwZcMQKTLuY<#{UMGw!ZoWdH}F#j&Dc!trO~U6)!1H zuMR$7I*;G7vp7B>DaCXbGa{HzLiS4>KLxkK6Oi?^*337){po7Tw1A=h7lS-0f`U~T zPj@EE2iZ(lRY^Y^PR8Sg38=%e_9<`oi~-p&!)rR#mi)#-BjgDXdXB3 zk%<~1EvYyXMS>Y)927>l&xS$Y(v@;cT*PA8kY-)R*7l$Q}EO6bDa*AuTSEQ5A$qgR~AcYKlZAGuHdj?%O%(F z<8SSWlU03(x3%(gS>bOuoVXV0W#o0xL#sP+LI2rTZ?lW1Rhfv8CxsMVx6udg&D^3Y zX*Xw?K8HhfMGaM3-$9>#*e)7%I*4N8%iXYCtZJg71mOxk_b2w z0hL5!QBVX9j|MWCC={42{Wn`h;UO?XF9Ma8Q&u5+y07P#*VDQi-~0(A8g2;3VvgN^ ziNs;)$~+q+1Sx{hT|yDIM;%aAy_+~bLHz$g){U9qe-j3Qf&aGcvbuPtW;ny}3M2q} z*2}c=d4j;J*zadf4Dzw5SJh1BL zLXR4&o5)$DYw=fXwO0G`m|ccP+ad5uTiCv;g!WhT?+q+Uyk2d7xBHloRT+bQ$;}!M zS-UNmR$q>(1-N~9ylTcV&9|GkvVH0OdS;gN-uv`s+g3Queg5uokzm4jeJlQ5J;ZP7 zVPYOK0_rKgPYv9)cDm`0sH1TykQRcP}{$~Hy%dz*LnYp8t_H@dGT+5x|(D??VB;+OT zAu`=BG<>FW|3M%}3Rl19i|(qMo|$a>E5)0$4!4GRrtNY0vhqF~XJs?u10VQ@?E}jO z|3yFC@4JUWVGZGWx8QWFIXNMaDU~G1fe_0ha$$)Nx3WFlT-G7caZW;TS8Niml;SRX zxI4iu+t!h=&A|+cfYu-ZV@gS7qyGnKz=Fnqkp}U*3qfJa_26fl*%gb>oAyo78~nq} zU_Io&%#6hRzK@dn>YnsRchq)^&j&l^zOYXg51m{c-0@)hHpYk}RP*txkr_}4le(92 z18@6TSEiH2i;94j~GGK?e#F3-XDGE_dhw2va=)M@ht|&LgwYj10%0m#}Ip* zZVwXsch6WA%U(L#UTE1O%*LfPU?=FrB!3AhRZfw`L8nzrlkH+j#(Pn$(dhGP{O9x2 zvb(k%WsNLSiNboaFI|VlP(zMI1uNv8U%=9H z>AMup9Z_poAu%sdN)ulAXij%=_D%S8w$C*g*|w$)l8#^p#$VKhO)NzgPfvecrnj-R z2>S;N!J^QA!BG155Q)*QW;qLIcq@BewIN2Wj=4=gc*SBS7@ee(!SZ0c>*VIZu_ze- zmn_(x;EG+$2ba{SPm~y)IE2`mizPnfr*pVdgxQ{&X?@r^NG~qF?D0^P2|PAZqAoUN*? zgWZg82zLw%YII4d+MFu0S#hu@PhXL1|D*ovhGMryw#Z$$O=5m#UvVzEl7BiJN)X#4 zakTS>G8?CRw`exzu5|>@^W=BW?i*gem&AQ;+h${F-oaOc9};DCMS7?l$o>M%L++hy z$^tT9qjLt>-kPI(k*xjqSPGBR*BxGg>ulP@cH$wOLx#r1vdI>5$$Z&1lW*TQXQ&z_ z{f!Tx^)I7Ru%i%Z#Y~ujw!XfSvA7cPxSg?=p&f|=6h)owJi&4%P-*;8om3_P#XYcE zDI)`cDY-a05`oGgSSqxD0>@ey#ly}XsFA{BQbEeZ;AbnzxaF&JPp(VIwu;PFtHJy6;N8h0S(0v&yT2AJFzIBfr@*8UU& z2&X_i_M}ijQ317Jpf3Nv_ziSXB2w%YRV!w&4T-)|LSc*GkN5Fq^nIP@Mrl*NVr0{Odn7Hag;? z6nn5Bi$?+=DB5|b5ozcF>Va~DPb85jEUn(^L;-+b6aGJ_{r{9$9jJc0*dHZ1xe-AW zwe5Upaspza0pty-M0aD5|4We#0K!av%C|wC^(bcn#lqqL7X4n^WHP!t|cBMcxX_#Ety!XnmM6b|hFZvEDc-<4gLWKAp*q)RRddqX!`;#w?+^QpdxJ~i0`j2fPiaL zAOVfRC!kb-6U~?ag91nWoCOpL4u{a5 z{g?oc#Y5K#G=w!90PWy+qG1i#1!xl+h-MFjY|! zg=2s{1Y`wm;2#Jt4eSYM7eHj#Nb5GS-h!Y2`wpSC;P(wg+v~OGV4t4^+6B0)VEZdq zvhi30`1-ZGE^C1Rz>#+81n~W|+bkPH39z-aXB#34?bia}y=k!n3T!#8!&)3d(meZG zpaG14_QVH@q=hmtoFIR!ON&UrO&GAlFAuivz`zSbDu5NNP4MgaZ~htq1Vq499|h)E z4^cm_48iQ}fHOES5Ox%~-VO1u-B9b@;8KA1U30p>t{|GPGOpdL`n4DkzJ8rF z6oK16R2MQy3A{!nrgR7iM#Squoq9&Ti+n+pNz zjgrDhAta#ARH_H%5De!2^N|$U(+L;^oKhUT?14K-8%KFKI6?___O3vL{V~IV4Vd|O z5*;CcSAjzS|MBAkxL*ultd7v1Jn-NHexRgv9v*`Rw*C(uQW}8b4;~7P@qh5pz=7v4 z9^h*K;sLMyA3QjaDfo*Ay3;@Up>cq;fAHW)IAGr3=a(L6Ea2+@;7P-Qu=58GCk=$8 zKY3`tUHrkrBmTw;jRWlo{QO!M0|(#5KX@oKV3>dKus}%qlPCT6x_}A&B{LR@|7$)h z8ugdHSPW>Qzpo2~oWJJ7!NF7F@BMHH>|fa9vG5K3sGfE%ZbVPol|yxsBN=eywD$#O mKqiB)5zQePy7&?SBLoeTLbdax(##ULo`--43oGlYK>i2Q)bf=8 literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/nature/fig/ts.pdf b/nature/fig/ts.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..953f5ff42d1753d264063f13053d2fa5d29b1b8f GIT binary patch literal 13682 zcmb`u1yohr6EH5)siZ+&N*Zp5gd*LgG{^-m-CPh+P#UD9Q>3I3DM2~~q(cw|B*j7y zQA7m3bK&`n_x`{CTi^O%&D!VA*)cPF&dlsHbNIC66ht9na4NpiX;4W$6$AtZxmeg! zNlJpmwXilg4-gc<=zzp8UUkKR#AUH~tfPw!NLrc-=WIpji2h}Oyf&f~r86$m z8KEq@kQH8UT#y6hS*+lJMoaH)mh5jYrkC$6S7|!$f9>k)9%`ArzR%$Da((Tcah-2R zOUv}aDs0bpm*MNXRaKSM*=vq9>nnG^oLfA(HD&yPSTf_rUUy#~rdmE^%8X_2^TQ+n?KX(RT`&_}7XZLo$ESF#2d()RZHF;|s%2;L z+>MV7E-m}7S21Y)$HBL35}3ZH`ZwHT>TS ztIm0=loW+3ynRzxBxjM?79TIfLaRuHO(2f?Wad+z?>ccxF-+=3hhPCmL`Sf%Xz!z; z*@lj)Pds@O!^au=>e`jXGza+luc22 zkxHKhp{UJWw9KK?M^vRmI>jXpmoe1RQ2S_x4o_phpBGru+?!s7G7)wE)L%)ur@2Zc^P zy^HT|B8%*^T5l2h$R?mN#C7UQ;aFzRKy*oHxZ&9h**UbDX7>0T^i|Wt(Hc56&!Fhf zrgMYc36>t-yh{ zV>qJtpO7tiaw>zi679l@L?l~?ML zwcP6ku1?DeXj=tO4>L#J>Iff3gud~c$mnpbTTnY=g`)Edwc%aj-XS6%>C%d8Q{l8z zntDdYZ<3q4phnUcUNo;Z)<)!DekxSz+=vLPSpL0e8w+0xaY4c3Zjp4gNAI>$2z*pY zpK<42r^$c`Y%BYpxns*Mqm~$$l{Yt~BAv6($kdw~ge3L!OWlN|yL$(J8~7lgT#YM3 z#mX+?kEe4x^ANT4bZvA-FO;Is*Dec%Gl;)9_2#BS+t_Uy)ayrSy3PWA@jOK@M~JE> zN5M~SZ&FsZeqj{}Z_bQcswTnC3c5a1whSEp=;%+vL^ZkzHsZ;X>)Vxx z+zAPxMbnTADqkQ|3~$1R8fun~Y4BoCvUrhw#-CYkxD8MEsEHPivt9`57>*L*y4|nk z`G8Iq)strva2}>jY9qDynauK4RF=gy^+^_;l5R2ERYz)TbvvIUK_e@}>>(jROCL!G zdwSWxv2unJ6WO=5uCYH!rq!)xBPA>+8tolvDGrLcyw()cT$80p~xU(7Y!CK1-_<~bWV zL~=19ohsg9WGVd2(<41qo^ucG(T0Z&3#O>2)5!`JkDRrD(+i_Q=O4KHxMSGN4eArD zH*RxM+`l)uE!JN|#sjg9H1PKmCx0QLWqb*V7L53CQ;XKm^fWEHa#>-JeBWLcdA#dH z2q|_XBd9sfE%c)5eQJd!?G{B)>x>UZd(^q$iJN!fAe$!qUSki+S@e+v{S9891?rCLtKk~gk2qAw(cJn9m&6K1r(S*X-JU{$vokT~pJpt7ohv_M7jd0eb0c@#12>-xG$JLSeX}YN^zH4EGj`Nr$vQ)+ILMp6Zvu6^m zoQp5axnBI4u9{}qRs3P80*JEHxQ)E9O{D#1yU@{={3IIelSCSuRzF^u;O1Z-Sw{a0 z43+f{HPr9go*AsLrsmZpA`;VgezJZ?(yGB+YF#8VSTTVjN>aO@oI{e+c93_)-Ge+J zn(_|!X)Tv3EGgyU1Bu289dorP&a+iyU^!WJzN2IbsqM2Pl)A|@h3fQy(fl-ArBtVU zjKcYfhxN|LQ&m6h33R2Pn0he^XMWXlj4hPaha>TJUq~VYm56e|d=YAket|gDD z+)~<3+V!NOfqQ3$=o7X&3URY{-V7ZAae=W}wyIzC7RDV_w9ef;GR)G?AU~Tcq;H?K zO*hzW?=R!c!fzLM|J#E}t+(yjoL!xL55l%Q<}K)Xp1-whr+-H}q?P$RphG@^n9hs2IJ>rDs@oLxYHgp5CM*VxX&5}Czv=b>0>gg1{83S+I z_cWm8MLgOr?FM$Wo?)sn``A7eYRGAk_klZ*`#CD-QHj|dDyl>;(a7#c}bSohxkinu0fp=>7T@4Sfm$EeyG9Vq2Y9032>pCMCOXwbR9y~4@d}hB^XTks7pZ-Po<0R%`KRmcdK^IywU{d? z-n^|a--rp#Ce9%%PEl(3F!r2Gvd}>ID0`5Pe@&eA6~>Sf@T%Zu{3jy|o1HFo;kNAL zH>b}z)(hY64OVV%nLE2#tkUnASfEv(>%~-jG?z89pw>0G;dJ`UmEt*>Bce9tO5jG& z=2M}27kZ9m*h-h);JnmIGT9$(IpUplS5QpVmdSK_$2WkIy69T_nR)VKPn9uXQpPIW zdv^ZTHosf^pmiDL)Rie+ecq5Wd7cC7k@LL`n^!YU_ld>r`McI{2kxcKFucw^A#HKg z-R$%37S(w)^VioL6oOZtkG6+I(7gI^Rs79hZ{>5l_7se8-HZ|Z`|PvK zLXSR+O8t&<#|Myx!HTuc7pwUELRF}saoN?mw-WsQ_<1xJzmRIH^0yx95AJkpVaLB; zxHiYwY-Mqg{P72f6>Bc$=uEV%$jH?7xz3h+iNFrd%KECHR_`wvSH8R6aJ>gF(-n(X zxpI!EJV7bWB@mm^zIYWr%S+Cgf~ohaG%%|+?_LxTlAwO>R?N&@#;@*bt984GtD?=M zjM^#+X;9QzC3{rMuL}!9Gz9mBx!2Ey^66p(5*^j`WmLw#^LmQuWSBb%q}{x6?fa1Y z#R5ac%Vm0zmLev#gC3bE*@a=P(}`-yizVE*I?4r(3bq&J381W{%O+K^l|8$R(mnnL zVj+A6rfo-feCNP-iY0DF9=jyzVe+xC*?b+Go#ZN8|AIyii*6V?O_w6ouo_EJV3WzN zPh_+(I(0lW+>1}!D&CJJyE>EUZ9Y$SFa&<=S=DSL4V_>`EK6P%Ts|c$q)?knL)!fq?4WQhTKXFWXOZ{s&JL4t6moW^oJ)Ogr zSLfEJik!Km$F!^jsk`UXXXv#Qj$FGhY)BhpJJVIhEZC?eRomAz9=&#AYb1@K_+n`> z#rvsw?&pl&*X_rxlI~^jXDp*(l9?0BEh-lrOULKreT%qJMO~^)WT8pIt9Kl6-A`w< zVw~qwoKPPPL^Wf`HCzSHa0>HZ_Q9B?U3wo!OzH4!qB4VDBRU7I!jas{B@6SEU~Cjd z_X-QCQF4y73q8J*ERU$jblj-rqNROtT+=fV9|>Rm>gUT^c9p5bnM4j-w4LF>vQ3k@ zM&n<7(c{rv&R{W{Z_77mf(3^pnR47$c4V1Il!%&Y1_)rZsX$wu$97@Q2& z_MTghv_8Rfjr9myW_B~(e9X;BN&j=$WrZhQwxTjM3sv?}ZgjI0$f@#|MP3ZpD%=SbE&kFg?wtVIaDBCB7=k+;kmke(G3b5!bsfLCAbaar2F_kvrP zJ^ZOU20ACZ8nZN{r@=KHcP20~tJn0I)8m%IpSw%#Qr|IJBP{ifHMHLL&sey}Fq%MP z_3Q)X@GB6wJGjJ}Q`%BSDP@oYd3~*!D)f>;%ym}!TLbqk^EvbdQ*A!oelSnY>XM@_ z4Swv_e#uEeeL#88?W||kv^r9X_hj^N@i7wm`D-46_0h?q8Cz5B$~*O$51{_9**Vd4 zptvHV@aJNWZXt>;aOwDB;*a|FUR^La(+hR%1nD{wQ{+gHdb4Ff$ zXWyTVt7fo}nCDp}dUw%5(j_rC{^jC2B_9NOWtsNe)-Bm$lyvE(l7^JVxzgS(Z;wh2 zJz;G|(Q*3@!7JKt##p2SKOgIwzE^?w_f$rBc#MvsGs#e4D<{*|71$oIwB!e;y*$VE z6`OQ+@KOF=CiDHrMrc;g?U*2PGYZX*&oR!@MP}jyvHaK5rkL2zFWaD$<3+))rhXO! z-Ucz$9F;_UUiB^OI&UeBOIQLoJf3>1YMiDx`$>MXQ8;zfhF=-dD>xXvh9zYaGp~9` zPW)lyEP2P8xF9BfC+wAp{l&?VcD{<|sx|B{Ulf^64j~FPqoop|`Q4lM9}c{ZySv1a z`$*gtNtPb-Sx43GIN7XTql0Eb$!Gr|g~71ovyBeN5nBdgMa2#bHOUJ}j0ic8;J{Zk z>8$y$unc=z;}yXsco#9ew$|I5eyoyFhy-u{kBE)Dg3SAd7u91qnha^599nPrz+Oq8H{bF7gjX?UoJyG)rAj{z#s@ zBu;^g+&kb=?! z=Rhv@O-Ta&O{T;3;2=JX#K`PiU_q3%erVTPxOw|FGk?h2`lt35l9lIN4JsJIKVOA^ zjTJ-ti|!~1^Ti7Uy(0b6+em9|m=H1Mu{~Ue)7{Nc%X<`4ZJzn`g_L#1c7VN6v1kt5 zk*OrqPf#8qNVNFLPiha6ylelw^0_b(#*V=*|9V@+I}*(s%;%mwxI)@0oZ2O<#CLX~ z<=cBhj%Oj{HAM|?lFIrX(4ME%mjG8&FQ!cxJlrDHvUpe0RT>`8_UUxRjkr|)!2(15 zd7HbTW<**h0c{e9)U;kTXuEHoOW-jx$#_~rVed7*aE0C{88anv?dlsI6B!Eqdki-p zr)qg!Mw?_kODB1e)$70JX8K8JLH45#mtlNv|5LRa`EE1c9*!hssPN6cY}*o2VB_Jx z!D^mfczh81?cEUpjv@TYgb1ztkPqkFRGb!C<vp67E-ZCM*mn~i$=XZOV#pPrmh zmmRxVy?FX4yQk;CT~Ua7O~O(+>HDY=!G}`U>S(g%)k~HfbN6;0#IMf=sISR#toPQb z$%SYeIVXnV1#-md)WAGbVqVI&8AqN#zj@yGPDZ_q$-=0F=ak;#yrAryfiFN zJ~kP46~MKr!>B*euqdM{GptKiBvaROsF(U26eXHpHu6QlO&K@4m+r0??R5Lh_S_p@ zy+;-=E-gz_u7BNwbH2XcX}NJwIcbpc?%oHIROeDp=ej{ru~i41IGx!w&dV>K(@T#_ zG~*LD_qY_YV##o3X^M?PyT?C-EQRkq|Nx9?n*(#IaB;Mn%o{vPf(Cu$$Qm)^Ly zAAfmy@8kXu#ZE_h!m$>Cy^R~?^n5#nw8~!@fWHzf2blpv3IPd$A%0|C4pJHfq%p|! zZyX^P@?UZdP#Bbuq4+z|fY4TU?gY~`>@a_CJu>m3k-sY|^vnLF&J!kz^L!8M_$(}W zj*3IRV#21s#vyXg_}RGYe;3gVR%|buQ)co{o;ULf=wp41J4XlOY)sZ0%zGS9(<6_R zlB9<|<2!y9+(72}%=&qFGuM0-kIsNX(%2-!=BNbnhRn z+ALh+vNfG4aI!2^Q0X3Pp;cFpqu7?Cw0Q{sz_NE^sHu5!=a>f9Mf!h{?60}2|CO9U z!G4n$42jeSYk}b;u?h-gRQc!iZgHJZY8~#8<4UIHrLb7OX-IbdbPk&Q{+Uo=;(ju_ z;6m~W(Ay}{sB9s6kuXOx{nJMZdQO!83qk)iTLgt;expcTTlp3-u!Aei-_CQH#Wxnn zrpm7DPd=dw#*k2!$Hgb57*HRB1aXQ;eU0VvK<%>nuP`1DHOA~ zU>e3cluf@bmF>V_Skd$mBa)ly(M--6Tt@=SCbINZhCV8MmB_`YLF36rXO!1o=U~yX zU^F5bHSN5kV2wKyL>psuVfy6FFwncBl_y0KkVr+JvST%XSRZtvDt_VQx`-%T?9DM2V9k@ugT0R;Lt3ChQ+x|4t?h zesR%j#oyfJD!tOw@t#<&lk5RrcTDydCbpaQ-9jXWYEIo}TU)r2GU3&I*&>eFgD7HJ zuyDme%xLn|+1Yql_fq~&$lxRMzaAbKhDu!5(*l2xKUQ#Yclwb_{*l7{)f6p4;b2`b5^rV=uH&DPGGV7o6?BGm$dYB!h=iEB`EMqHsZA8MqVK%V#XfC*OA_@t zU+2@>v4qU`r3)eNh>l)3ZT&B#5z^oPg)|5P{F_EfX=3O)z%(y*sr*1UJq;et#&f^E zy?3MRbrw4beU^7mWv(SD9mHR`n=L%Kn)5q6>byu`8jsI~F0hCzQrSOLMo(E^+Bidv ztA^A}>FWfOB&)hrKxTIsdtH3*YvMH>;|kB$M61Uy@tRiASXPwPyGmh65M4gZuRen< z!{Ze1UQ&HWM9TPebo<5!=QS^1BJ(crfvfr5J3$GV{{O}vjCoM~*~Sn0xvuyRW-zc_`D%)862x|FV6Aa)tlG9}EWnjXzNxRrf9s z%?l4I(=6Cm@+HYP_#@aFy$ZpxWGt&f2K{^TG4wCH=ueN-uiO zhV|W!sEZQ~z9uKK1nHFQ3|K4q$icB)+TUA6{#bnK$}!d5DsTURM~td3ot>dGy?N9E;sniqqJAp9g9Z#d#0d95p@6 z&RjOKd32Uzh`jg9{b%$#4M&-RAHfDa<^{&|6slRgkV^I@jxN!=1}ekB&L#@Ccy8Y< z;+D+H>+L^7wGflR;VwjseVcY4@6LM3tst`>kseVCQ?`EBtW=TOe$^CRwMV0CU2~Ox z$USGgh+?h6Ms;`?b3d~w$!$Yet)Q7Fr+S6>jC&ELw`gRhVm@Ks=*vY~%&)nLA%*qf10o6kR^OKUsNc=C<{MX0} z^1IW4A*;2(H#?YQ@57IQwaI5S#G1z+@k6p$??=0JRhnUm|(!;iH^Nzw9#(ieSn^p5q;g_b_<S(&JNFZw}5E;!~(wIegfPLTW`R* zj(Y{v-P;c<%9nfCV>k?$d9vkNpM0 zm3>vTk}Rw#HR%==yIweppUlTB#VFq|CodX+MpoIBT_eM_VsCo+KUbo`Toduq=G=q{ zKp0;?XO*9p@#l+6!F1K*H(!1ouE^SZ7Kv&(EA+PA&4`{4QkA066oPOOk4>@I1JBb@V z{@%1)DpjVp)TEP-@r2q_ERPM{xm2iFwTBc6w4z{;jJ@rwcN)eJ4G&i03NB918zhlo zh`g^5g>+}yxhEcj54jXo2zl=z>U4QX9qlmu-k@}2DS^Y(O^pA9cq!ZFXC(0nZM)Kq z^GdC|&c{A`RK~ybR$Uon8C$$I(7Vxo(Yz~t()m2{>B7s#u*IFo@|BhC@5GnQjl=#$ zhQG#4|0^g$A%A;Xr6MKhZUWA5E2CY}){mF`LYV*TjeCOC5xbkbFSAp^-1b{^oiDgq3OTIMoQ7&>Au zn)h4Gd*^v0#l1Ci1P1n61|moFIND4?suQ?UH+13)xt4XMeNx3T>Zd3B?cpm))uJ9Z z>mD|Wm&LV)TZaX<*`?GGrAZRWPL336%bwsE9>1q6@L-xm`c|#;u^G!6|Kx{UE8!pu zfm0$f14Z(TEKWoGd59LX2-ex;)tMgMdykV&`jZjqq1h&1Pp&6QX`UIuGegHq5Pc^p z8RfYpx1;l)GQKl{k3t#7AJdoG6E{lif;EmDVRY*|YIRp7p=znqrDC&+O#j;+(Ot!h zN&l1&!1Yg8aslgsJ1ANdzo4$IEvF|ehqK4(dFo=FJ%HjzTdX^wY!Rp^{HqF4-We$3 zBUB|yN>Yi-*;!lTfC@oENuV(ZIAe=@xMD4VT1YTR+?7x|=!mlhN*oU^-R*2_@gO)F zB<_QAcL9mJI0L1C_$$B_-qsz510i4_aces-92EiqOoQ{n0diBf&lc31H|EhU>sP|2Y4UwSFPsX!~uQ*h|t|V@B{_`X2l5{{{KbvKo>cjho!rn zE8fK&1UV?^1f~Jd>R7zH-9gc$7#K`Yc;NrEg73j{31Yc zgTLwfg`FQ~17i>p4E}!sRR6d0z<|&M4(uiz2?n8IXb=*Hq{09v5)>LJj71?pFbwzr z5CENo`-J{5B;>G#p$Pr|7f}7U4+HuVfH21oK)@h?HWLJZh64ahgh7K)K;(u59wG#= zIEnxWC%^O#Go-idx#^n z2h6}wRD_m51c5060B_h1#v%a559a{-0_z@J1Mxi+g+2fT3Ukn6PyoFE9tnX03?8lv z2i8RZhh!LrFb)nv04*927NI==D4`$nKnR4Eu>QfO5d;X(00@?fuqFZ+b0Cx-#1Yy9 zO(U!XC;R{tL_{E)z#5?i;9y?}%N+t00$}lABtgDEF8~4$r+@++6YdbG0x18X20ymz zM+lVjymb1x{taKyex9-`&IjLwsm|e}0Sb zOGns`j*$P^4gRAWSnPjv{DrAsLWrN7{IY*Pk-wc3A)-IS3sEOKXHQ@o4u$t~z^~Dp ztcxe$)&P=J?W_nf2B5YC;Q~JQkmth>Hhzu;&V)Zh8(HA90=%7zvmD|33<0^bP%sn< zM!>)j6c_`B34@{hU@*TRmH0tFz~u`7e%{s51@CBQ0rG;0A;cgeAX_}%)#I$VxYOUa z#9Z8MfI&c5WaViIeBAKsC|4_MkOkJ#0dU@b%^>)T%)H%k)>MGOf>Qye>90S)vIAdV zfUH4(;|P%!;Sc2e7Y+hNfdO&< ze(-ISva>Z{^8ld{zWmW~aUndG2iLlGJ~%+B35xE4$GYPW)EolEK%rE8eDazKRR0Gh C6s-#Y literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/nature/main.tex b/nature/main.tex index 426b0ab..088c5e0 100644 --- a/nature/main.tex +++ b/nature/main.tex @@ -1,6 +1,7 @@ \documentclass[a4paper, twocolumn]{article} \usepackage{polyglossia} \usepackage{authblk} \usepackage[sfdefault]{inter} +\usepackage{graphicx} \setmainlanguage{english} @@ -74,8 +75,41 @@ calibrated using photographs from the storm of February 28, 2017. Results from t to the analytical equations provided by \textcite{nandasena2011}. \section{Results} +\subsection{Identified wave} + +Preliminary work with the photographer allowed to identify the time at which the block displacement event happened. +Using the data from the wave buoy located 1250m offshore of the Artha breakwater, a seamingly abnormally large wave of +14m amplitude was identified that is supposed to have lead to the block displacement. + +Initial analysis of the buoy data plotted in Figure~\ref{fig:wave} shows that the movement of the buoy follows two +orbitals that correspond to an incident wave direction. These results would indicate that the identified wave is +essentially an incident wave, with a minor reflected component. + +\begin{figure*} + \centering + \includegraphics{fig/ts.pdf} + \includegraphics{fig/out_orbitals.pdf} + \caption{\textit{Left}: Free surface measured during the extreme wave measured on February 28, 2017 at 17:23UTC. + \textit{Right}: Trajectory of the wave buoy during the passage of this particular wave.}\label{fig:wave} +\end{figure*} + \subsection{Reflection analysis} +The results from the large scale SWASH model using two configurations --- one of them being the real bathymetry, and +the other being a simplified bathymetry without the breakwater --- are compared in Figure~\ref{fig:swash}. The results +obtained with both simulations show a maximum wave amplitude of 13.9m for the real bathymetry, and 12.1m in the case +where the breakwater is removed. + +The 13\% difference between those values highlights the existence of a notable amount of reflection at the buoy. +Nonetheless, the gap between the values is still fairly small and the extreme wave identified on February 28, 2017 at +17:23:08 could still be considered as an incident wave. + +\begin{figure*} + \centering + \includegraphics{fig/maxw.pdf} + \caption{Free surface obtained with the SWASH model in two configurations. \textit{Case 1}: With breakwater; + \textit{Case 2}: Without breakwater.}\label{fig:swash} +\end{figure*} \section{Discussion}